
‘AI vs human’ isn’t the fight your brand should be having
When I’m shopping online, I don’t look for ‘perfect’ brands. In fact, they scare me a little. What I’m drawn to, and what keeps me interested, are the brands I can see myself in – imperfections and all. Ones that feel tactile and squishy. Ones that don’t try too hard.
It’s not that I’m looking for mistakes; I just like to know there’s a real-life human on the other side. And the best brands are getting this too. At Shaped By, we’re seeing it more often than not, B2B brands leaning into their human-ness, even when they are literally selling AI-powered tech. Ironic, eh?
This isn’t about labelling AI as bad and humans as good. It’s about staying grounded in what makes us human, even as technology transforms the world around us.
Author: Sarah Healey, Content Editor, Shaped By
The “AI slop” backlash
There’s been, what feels like, a worldwide crackdown on AI-generated content. In July 2026, LinkedIn introduced its “seems like AI slop” button – clicked over a million times since launch. Hari Srinivasan, LinkedIn’s Chief Product Officer, reported that members are now seeing 40% fewer views of “AI slop”. Other social platforms are following suit, with Pinterest now labelling AI-generated imagery, and Snapchat having stopped recommending AI-generated videos altogether.
And why is this all happening? Because of growing consumer frustration. People don’t want the overly-polished, the overly-perfect. They want content that is real and that fits into their own worlds. The backlash that followed Levi’s partnership with Lalaland.ai, which used AI to replace paid model work, is a case in point, forcing the brand to issue a clarifying statement within days. Coca Cola’s AI-generated Christmas ads have landed with similar effect, with some social media users even calling for a full boycott of the multi-billion dollar franchise.
The rise of imperfection
It might be an odd concept – B2B companies that sell AI, pushing for their brand to appear and feel human. Or… is it genius?
Despite being a GTM platform with agentic AI at its core, Clay adopts a “refreshingly imperfect” design system. In an article for It’s Nice That, Clay’s artist-in-residence, Hudson Christie says that he’s learning to “wear imperfection a bit more confidently,” and that “the idiosyncrasies of real artists will continue to be a major hurdle for LLMs.” With its warm, tactile, and purposefully wobbly visual identity, Clay has managed to do what many other tech companies can’t – break away from the industry’s tired tropes. We recently headed to London to speak with Sara Lundberg, Manager of Brand & Creative at Clay, to dig into this a bit more. Listen to the full conversation today.
It’s not just Clay adopting this approach, but many other brands; Adobe’s 2024 Creative Trends Report noted a 30% rise in searches for hand-drawn design elements. The industry calls this pledge to imperfection “naive design,” a nod to the late 19th-century art movement by the same name, where self-taught artists worked outside of convention. And whilst we can’t claim to be quite as pioneering as Henri Rousseau, it’s clear that challenging the norm still pays off.
This isn’t AI vs Human
Nothing is beyond error, and AI’s polish doesn’t change that, but understanding its limits matters just as much as understanding what it unlocks.
AI – used specifically, and well – doesn’t immediately deter people from brands, in fact it can work in their favour. A study by Yahoo found that, when disclosed on ads, AI lifted the appeal by 47% and overall brand trust by 96%. There’s clearly a place for AI in our lives and our brands. The real challenge is knowing how to use it to bring out the best in our people, without getting carried away.
For people in B2B, getting that balance right is paramount. Your buyers read case studies in the midst of their busy lives, which means you only have a few seconds to grab attention. By sounding/ looking synthetic, they are likely to move on.
So how can you get the balance?
It’s not a one-size fits all approach. Every brand is unique, with different requirements and goals. But there are some universal rules for using AI in your brand marketing that may provide some direction – especially for those in B2B. Let’s get into them:
Start human, end human
Good design should be bookended by human judgement, and no one is more adamant on this than Shaped By’s Design Director, Tom Sydenham. He makes sure to keep human craft at either end of the process – drawing initial storyboards by hand, then fine-tuning and recontextualising the AI-generated illustrations across other tools and processes before they’re finished. For Tom, using AI well means applying “the same critical eye” you’d bring to any collaborator’s work.
Read the full article here: exploring the impact of AI in character illustration.
Break the workflow on purpose
There is no rule that says one tool has to do the whole job. Generate an image, then take it into Photoshop, Illustrator or Figma. Or print it, cut it up and rebuild it by hand. Every handoff is a chance to leave your fingerprint and build something better than what came before it.
Fill the tank offscreen
Galleries, articles, walks, doodling, being outside, whatever actually moves you. AI should never be your first port of call for inspiration. Your taste is built from what you have seen and what has moved you. An AI model can’t bring an emotive pulse to your work; it has to come from you.
Use AI, but don’t lose yourself
The AI conversation is ever-changing and the only way to stay (somewhat) ahead is by keeping in the loop. While AI has an important role to play in modern day workflows, some things will always need to remain stubbornly, gloriously human. Having a shared understanding of exactly what those things are is critical. We’ll end with the words of the famous Scottish Art Nouveau designer, Charles Rennie Mackintosh: “There is hope in honest error, none in the icy perfections of the mere stylist.”
For more insight on how human judgement and AI can best work together, listen to this session – featuring Buck Choate, VP Corporate Marketing at Pendo; Tom Sydenham, Designer at Shaped By; and Mette Davis, AI Coach at Spark AI – from our recent BYOB virtual event on navigating the AI/human partnership.

















































