Insights

How to become a Creative Director

Lessons from Simon Tandy & Justin Ballantine

The paths of our lives are rarely - if ever - linear. There are ups and downs, lefts and rights, spirals and hiccups. The same goes for our careers; that unsteady, inevitable climb upwards, losing your footing here and there, deciding that - actually - I want to be on that ladder over there, not this one. And sometimes, if we’re lucky, it all works out. We get to do something we love. Like actually love.

Sarah Healey

Two creative directors on a purple and yellow background

In this article, we join two of our very own Shape-lings - Simon Tandy and Justin Ballantine - as they reflect on the career turns and lessons that shaped their (recently appointed) Creative Director roles in Design and Brand Messaging.

In what is perhaps unusual for a creative agency of our size, at Shaped By we have multiple Creative Directors- each serving a unique purpose. Here, we dig into those purposes deeper, exploring how the role differs between verbal identity and visual design, and what it takes to go from being the one doing the craft to leading it.

Simon Tandy: from Junior Designer to Creative Director of Design

What was the moment that made you realise design was the career for you?


It started at college, when a local agency set us a brief to create a brand identity for a window manufacturer. The challenge was figuring out how to take something that felt fairly dry and turn it into something with real knock-out appeal. I came up with a laser-cut logo that worked as a stencil, allowing you to see through it to the prints underneath. I actually came runner-up at the awards ceremony, which was a real moment for me. I realised then that I probably wasn't too bad at this.

Can you talk us through your career to date?


After uni I landed a job at a publishing house, where I worked as a Junior Designer. It was a brilliant grounding in design, but also in understanding how creative work comes together and what it takes to get a product out in the wild, under punchy time pressures.

Alongside that, my Creative Director had started a side hustle: a design agency called Bang. The projects were relatively small-scale, but the demand grew to the point where we could no longer juggle the agency with the magazines. So, we took the leap, jumped ship and went all in on building an agency, called The Group of Seven.

Eventually, I realised I wanted to broaden my horizons and get stuck into a wider mix of branding projects. That’s what brought me to Shaped By, or Workbrands as it was known then. It was the opportunity to push myself creatively, work with a different range of clients and really get under the skin of what makes brands tick. Looking back, every step has helped shape the way I approach design today.

What does the jump from Design Director to Creative Director of Design entail and what does the role ask of you that it didn’t before?


Stepping into the Creative Director role has given me a more elevated view of our project work. It's an exciting shift because you're not just thinking about how to make the work great (our designers do an awesome job of that) you're thinking about how all the pieces fit together, how the story comes to life and how the creative vision can make the biggest possible impact.

One of the main challenges is translating that bigger-picture thinking to clients in a way that really resonates. It’s about bringing them on the journey, helping them understand the thinking behind the work and, just as importantly, making sure they feel heard and invested in the process.

What’s one project/piece of work you’re most proud of?

The rebrand of Shaped By stands out for me because there was so much riding on it. I mean, how often do you get the chance to rebrand yourself? It's no mean feat, particularly when you're an agency whose entire business is built around helping other brands define who they are and how they show up in the world.

It was a huge moment for us as an agency because we were going all in. We were completely rethinking our proposition, our identity and even our name. We had the opportunity to redefine who we were and what we wanted to stand for.

The brilliant thing was that we were given complete creative freedom. Our CEO, Nick, put an enormous amount of trust in us and essentially said, come back with the best possible version of what Shaped By could look like. Having that level of belief from the very top was huge for us as a creative team. It gave us the confidence to push boundaries, experiment and really explore what was possible.

A year from now, what do you want people to say about Shaped By's design work?

Over the next year, I want us to become the creative agency that the world's most ambitious tech companies turn to when they're ready to do something that genuinely moves the needle. Not just an agency that makes things look great, but a creative partner that helps businesses challenge convention, think bigger and bring bold ideas to life.

For me, that means being more ambitious in the work we put out into the world, pushing ourselves creatively and making sure we're always looking for opportunities to do something unexpected. We want to be working with businesses that are shaping the future, helping them define who they are and giving them the confidence to stand out in increasingly crowded markets.

What's changed about what creative leadership in design demands right now, compared to even a few years ago? How will you navigate those changes?

The biggest change is the pace at which everything moves. We're working in a landscape where businesses are evolving at an incredible rate, particularly in tech, and brands are under constant pressure to keep up to stay relevant. That makes it more important than ever to create identities that aren't just visually distinctive today, but have the foundations to grow and evolve well into the future.

For me, it all comes back to getting the fundamentals right. If you build a brand around an authentic story, a clear proposition and a strong idea, you give it something much more enduring than a visual identity alone. Rather than constantly rebranding and reinventing themselves, businesses can focus on evolving their brand in meaningful ways, allowing it to flex and adapt as they grow without losing sight of who they are.

As Creative Director of Design, I see it as my responsibility to create the conditions for great ideas to happen. Giving people the confidence to take risks, the support to push their thinking and the time to explore different possibilities. Technology will continue to change how we work, but the value of human craft, curiosity and creative instinct will always be at the heart of what we do.

Justin Ballantine: from Trevor Beattie wannabe to Creative Director of Verbal

How did you get into writing? Why are words so important to you?

My first taste of writing was for my University magazine. I wrote a couple of articles - one on holidays down to Greece (IYKYK), and another on the explosion of football shirts as a style choice. Bear in mind, this was the mid/late 90s. Music, fashion, culture, art, even politics - everything was colliding. I just loved, and still do, how words can connect different people around shared feelings and shared ideas. Cool Brittania, anyone? I mean, we hate-love on it now but then. It was powerful. Words and ideas are powerful.

After I left Uni, one of my friends, who worked as a Journalist, sent me a job ad for a trainee copywriter. I applied and remember loving doing the copy test. It was a made-up brief to recruit people to work at B&Q - I still remember the headline, “More variety than a night out with the Spice Girls”, because we were trying to reach summer jobbing students. So yeah, I was hooked, and from there I built the way up to Creative Director.

I’m a copywriter. (Never *shudder* a wordsmith.) I love the power of words. I love playing loose and fast with language. I love that we can flex and adapt our voice to meet people where they are, to connect with them emotionally.

How does your Creative Director of Verbal role at Shaped By compare to the ones you've held before?

Everywhere I’ve worked, everyone I’ve worked with, has taught me something different. A new way of thinking about a problem. A subject area I’d never got my head into. A really smart technique I could blatantly steal.

Working with new people and hearing different voices is so important. It makes us better. It’s not like being a Doctor where there’s clearly a right way to do things and a wrong way to do things. Our world doesn’t work like that. It’s kind of nuanced, more subjective. What’s right for one project isn’t necessarily right for the next. The more you have in your armoury, the better.

I guess the big difference with my role at Shaped By is that I don’t think I’ve ever worked in an industry that’s moving so fast. The B2B tech landscape changes by the day. Genuinely. And yes, I’m looking at you, AI.

Right now we’re talking a lot about the idea of brand momentum. I think it’s never been more important. Brands can’t be fixed in one place at one time. They have to keep moving. Conversations have to keep moving. Because the world keeps moving.

Do you have a piece of work/project you're especially proud of?

Diplomatic answer but… not really. I find it tricky to pick one. I do love the fact that from a copy point of view, sometimes a lot of what we do actually goes unseen in many ways.

There are lots of punchy scripts, emotive scripts, positioning statements, hero lines, headlines. But as the truism goes, your favourite piece of work is often the one you’re working on right now. So let’s say that.

I get a real buzz working with Alex, our Strategic Director. Taking the strategic idea into a creative idea. And then working with Si and the designers to develop that organising thought into its visual and verbal yin-and-yang parts.

Words are easy to nitpick; how do you handle a room full of people who have different opinions on brand tone of voice?

For one, take yourself out of the picture. This is brand voice. (Okay, brand voice can come from founder voice but that’s a different blog.) We’re defining the tone of voice for a brand, not for an individual. It’s about trying to make something that’s subjective, less subjective… which is tricky.

It’s why I prefer principles over guidelines. Principles give people a little bit more freedom to play and bring some of themselves and their experience to the brand voice. I want that for brands. You want to create a tone of voice that people actually want to play with.

We couldn’t do an interview on writing without mentioning AI: what’s your take on where AI fits into the future of writing, if at all?

There are so many ways we can use AI. Search engine, sounding board, sycophantic BFF. But I find it - springboards.ai especially - great for shaping and stress-testing my early creative thoughts.

Gen AI also helps to overcome what Hemingway called “The White Bull’’. The blank page. Sometimes you just need a bit of a kickstart and AI can be super helpful for getting something down.

So yes, I see AI as a net positive. Just as Excel didn’t replace accountants, it’s a tool creative professionals can use. On their terms. But I also hear, very loudly, the regulation conversation. You can’t have the AI power brokers policing themselves. That never ends well.

For more information on the interplay of verbal and visual brand identity, watch our BYOB session where Justin and Simon unpack how the two work in harmony: Yin needs Yang: Your visual and verbal brands in powerful harmony

Related Content